Israel is a revelation. Though we’d read about the country for years and formulated many opinions (“There must be a two state solution!”), we never truly understood the complexities and the nuances of the country until we stepped foot there. (As a side note, we are beyond impressed how Obama struck such a perfect tone during his visit there and threaded the needle with such unsurprising precision.)
While we delayed our visit by a couple months because of rising tensions in the region, we arrived into the bosom of many passionate intellectuals, going about their lives without anxiety or fear, each with unquestionable love for their country, and (if we might read subtly between the lines) the slightest glimmer of hope for a better tomorrow.
Israelis live with an existential reality that the rest of the world doesn’t possess. Because the country was born from the horrors of the Holocaust — an explicit program to exterminate the Jewish people — the Israelis possess the notion that at any moment their country could cease to exist. As Americans, we have our share of anxieties, but none of them include the idea that one day there could be no more America. This existential reality is part of the Israeli DNA, it explains the oversize personalities we encountered, the passionate way in which they live, the fierceness in their voice when they talk about their homeland, and the tight knit bond they feel with their countrymen.
We met many young men and women who were either in the midst of their compulsory military service or on the verge of heading off to the army. Their mothers were full of trepidation just as any military mother would fear for the safety of their children. But the military — the required service that every Israeli must complete (except for the Ultra-Orthodox, another story in itself and the root of many current domestic arguments) — the military is the remarkable key to not only Israel’s military strength, but it is the thread that weaves their society together and makes the country such a special place.
In the U.S., because we are not required to sacrifice years of service to our country, we live in our bubbles. The wealthy in America go from private schools to private colleges, generally keeping social and professional relationships in a narrow sphere. But the compulsory military service in Israel takes every eighteen year old in the country and tosses them into the same stew. Rich and poor, northerners and southerners, kids from Tel Aviv, kids from Jerusalem, and kids who grew up on kibbutz all unite for a common experience, sleeping in the same barracks, enduring the same daily anxieties — which creates a country bound by common experience. This impressed us beyond words.
We don’t believe, at this point in our history, that compulsory military service is required in America. But watching the example of Israel and the way these two years of forced integration and co-habitation bind generation after generation, we are inspired that compulsory national service — be it helping to build infrastructure, build schools, teach, participating in government or charity — would be an incredible and invaluable thing for our own country. That was our first takeaway from Israel.
And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Welcome to the Middle East.
Thank you for this at the start of Passover..I hope you will write more about your experiences there. I just saw The Gatekeepers, an Israeli documentary about their secret service. It was agonizing and very open. I have great respect for those men who were interviewed.
It must be very, very special to be there for Passover and I am sure this will be one visit you will never forget. I can’t wait to hear more…
Thank you for your remarks and your insight. Your comments about ” living in our bubbles” are spot on.
“…we are inspired that compulsory national service — be it helping to build infrastructure, build schools, teach, participating in government or charity — would be an incredible and invaluable thing for our own country.”
TOTALLY AGREE.
Thank you for another fascinating report!
Thanks for the report from Israel and Happy Passover. love,Wendy
Ahhh, you have finally reached the Jewish Homeland!
The image of the flag, your insightful words…like Obama, the perfect tone.
Do you take requests?
A report from Yad Vasheem?
xxx,#1FANNY
Thanks for the suggestion. We’ll do a little something about Yad Vasheem just for you.
Chag Sameach! Happy Passover to the Levin-Flackett family – celebrating this year in Israel!
Three years ago, we spent a very special Passover with my aunt and uncle who live in Jerusalem. It was Susannah’s and Wally’s first time in Israel. It was such a rich experience. While in Jerusalem, I suggest you make time to see the other Wall – the big concrete one that looks like a giant scar across the face of Jerusalem. A grim reminder of what you guys called the “existential reality” of modern life in Israel. I hope I live to see a great change in Palestinian-Israeli relations so that thing can be torn down!
Happy Passover!
Hi!
i’m the one who sat near Franny and Finn on the flight from tel aviv to prague.
you left such a huge mark on me!.. i told everybody i know about you with such amazment and excitment.
i was left with so many questions that i wouldnt know where to being. i think that the only way to be fully answered would be to take that couragous amazing move that you took and take my own trip…
i was waiting to see what you will write about israel and those words are amazing.
as someoneo who is israeli and lives outside of israel for many years, i often get into debats with others about israel and now i have something new to say
keep living the dream! for now all the rest of us can taste a bit of it through you!
iris
I completely agree with the idea of compulsory national service! I think programs like City Year are a step in the right direction, but it would be great if everyone would pitch in and roll up their sleeves for a year or two before college or work begins. Plus, experience in the world might really help to shape choices made about education and work.
Also, I have never been to Israel, but just from reading about it and what little history I know, it is obvious that only extremely skilled diplomats will be able to broker a peaceful, long term arrangement there. We all need to be honest about what has happened in Israel, but also realistic about what it is now. We need to somehow recognize and respect both things. Someday I’ll visit there. And I hope to be hopeful!
Looking forward to more thoughts from the intrepid travelers.